promhttp: Correctly detect invalid metric and label names

Without this fix, the `InstrumentHandler...` middlewares get locked in
an endless loop in case of an invalid Collector, eating all the memory.

Signed-off-by: beorn7 <beorn@grafana.com>

prometheus/promhttp/instrument_server.go

@@ -43,14 +43,14 @@ func InstrumentHandlerInFlight(g prometheus.Gauge, next http.Handler) http.Handl
 
 // InstrumentHandlerDuration is a middleware that wraps the provided
 // http.Handler to observe the request duration with the provided ObserverVec.
-// The ObserverVec must have zero, one, or two non-const non-curried labels. For
+// The ObserverVec must have valid metric and label names and must have zero,
-// those, the only allowed label names are "code" and "method". The function
+// one, or two non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only allowed label
-// panics otherwise. The Observe method of the Observer in the ObserverVec is
+// names are "code" and "method". The function panics otherwise. The Observe
-// called with the request duration in seconds. Partitioning happens by HTTP
+// method of the Observer in the ObserverVec is called with the request duration
-// status code and/or HTTP method if the respective instance label names are
+// in seconds. Partitioning happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if
-// present in the ObserverVec. For unpartitioned observations, use an
+// the respective instance label names are present in the ObserverVec. For
-// ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that partitioning of Histograms is
+// unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that
-// expensive and should be used judiciously.
+// partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used judiciously.
 //
 // If the wrapped Handler does not set a status code, a status code of 200 is assumed.
 //
@@ -79,12 +79,13 @@ func InstrumentHandlerDuration(obs prometheus.ObserverVec, next http.Handler) ht
 }
 
 // InstrumentHandlerCounter is a middleware that wraps the provided http.Handler
-// to observe the request result with the provided CounterVec.  The CounterVec
+// to observe the request result with the provided CounterVec. The CounterVec
-// must have zero, one, or two non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only
+// must have valid metric and label names and must have zero, one, or two
-// allowed label names are "code" and "method". The function panics
+// non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only allowed label names are
-// otherwise. Partitioning of the CounterVec happens by HTTP status code and/or
+// "code" and "method". The function panics otherwise. Partitioning of the
-// HTTP method if the respective instance label names are present in the
+// CounterVec happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if the respective
-// CounterVec. For unpartitioned counting, use a CounterVec with zero labels.
+// instance label names are present in the CounterVec. For unpartitioned
+// counting, use a CounterVec with zero labels.
 //
 // If the wrapped Handler does not set a status code, a status code of 200 is assumed.
 //
@@ -110,14 +111,15 @@ func InstrumentHandlerCounter(counter *prometheus.CounterVec, next http.Handler)
 
 // InstrumentHandlerTimeToWriteHeader is a middleware that wraps the provided
 // http.Handler to observe with the provided ObserverVec the request duration
-// until the response headers are written. The ObserverVec must have zero, one,
+// until the response headers are written. The ObserverVec must have valid
-// or two non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only allowed label names
+// metric and label names and must have zero, one, or two non-const non-curried
-// are "code" and "method". The function panics otherwise. The Observe method of
+// labels. For those, the only allowed label names are "code" and "method". The
-// the Observer in the ObserverVec is called with the request duration in
+// function panics otherwise. The Observe method of the Observer in the
-// seconds. Partitioning happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if the
+// ObserverVec is called with the request duration in seconds. Partitioning
-// respective instance label names are present in the ObserverVec. For
+// happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if the respective instance
-// unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that
+// label names are present in the ObserverVec. For unpartitioned observations,
-// partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used judiciously.
+// use an ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that partitioning of Histograms is
+// expensive and should be used judiciously.
 //
 // If the wrapped Handler panics before calling WriteHeader, no value is
 // reported.
@@ -139,15 +141,15 @@ func InstrumentHandlerTimeToWriteHeader(obs prometheus.ObserverVec, next http.Ha
 }
 
 // InstrumentHandlerRequestSize is a middleware that wraps the provided
-// http.Handler to observe the request size with the provided ObserverVec.  The
+// http.Handler to observe the request size with the provided ObserverVec. The
-// ObserverVec must have zero, one, or two non-const non-curried labels. For
+// ObserverVec must have valid metric and label names and must have zero, one,
-// those, the only allowed label names are "code" and "method". The function
+// or two non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only allowed label names
-// panics otherwise. The Observe method of the Observer in the ObserverVec is
+// are "code" and "method". The function panics otherwise. The Observe method of
-// called with the request size in bytes. Partitioning happens by HTTP status
+// the Observer in the ObserverVec is called with the request size in
-// code and/or HTTP method if the respective instance label names are present in
+// bytes. Partitioning happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if the
-// the ObserverVec. For unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero
+// respective instance label names are present in the ObserverVec. For
-// labels. Note that partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used
+// unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that
-// judiciously.
+// partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used judiciously.
 //
 // If the wrapped Handler does not set a status code, a status code of 200 is assumed.
 //
@@ -174,15 +176,15 @@ func InstrumentHandlerRequestSize(obs prometheus.ObserverVec, next http.Handler)
 }
 
 // InstrumentHandlerResponseSize is a middleware that wraps the provided
-// http.Handler to observe the response size with the provided ObserverVec.  The
+// http.Handler to observe the response size with the provided ObserverVec. The
-// ObserverVec must have zero, one, or two non-const non-curried labels. For
+// ObserverVec must have valid metric and label names and must have zero, one,
-// those, the only allowed label names are "code" and "method". The function
+// or two non-const non-curried labels. For those, the only allowed label names
-// panics otherwise. The Observe method of the Observer in the ObserverVec is
+// are "code" and "method". The function panics otherwise. The Observe method of
-// called with the response size in bytes. Partitioning happens by HTTP status
+// the Observer in the ObserverVec is called with the response size in
-// code and/or HTTP method if the respective instance label names are present in
+// bytes. Partitioning happens by HTTP status code and/or HTTP method if the
-// the ObserverVec. For unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero
+// respective instance label names are present in the ObserverVec. For
-// labels. Note that partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used
+// unpartitioned observations, use an ObserverVec with zero labels. Note that
-// judiciously.
+// partitioning of Histograms is expensive and should be used judiciously.
 //
 // If the wrapped Handler does not set a status code, a status code of 200 is assumed.
 //
@@ -198,6 +200,11 @@ func InstrumentHandlerResponseSize(obs prometheus.ObserverVec, next http.Handler
 	})
 }
 
+// checkLabels returns whether the provided Collector has a non-const,
+// non-curried label named "code" and/or "method". It panics if the provided
+// Collector does not have a Desc or has more than one Desc or its Desc is
+// invalid. It also panics if the Collector has any non-const, non-curried
+// labels that are not named "code" or "method".
 func checkLabels(c prometheus.Collector) (code bool, method bool) {
 	// TODO(beorn7): Remove this hacky way to check for instance labels
 	// once Descriptors can have their dimensionality queried.
@@ -225,6 +232,10 @@ func checkLabels(c prometheus.Collector) (code bool, method bool) {
 
 	close(descc)
 
+	// Make sure the Collector has a valid Desc by registering it with a
+	// temporary registry.
+	prometheus.NewRegistry().MustRegister(c)
+
 	// Create a ConstMetric with the Desc. Since we don't know how many
 	// variable labels there are, try for as long as it needs.
 	for err := errors.New("dummy"); err != nil; lvs = append(lvs, magicString) {

prometheus/promhttp/instrument_server_test.go

@@ -25,6 +25,7 @@ import (
 
 func TestLabelCheck(t *testing.T) {
 	scenarios := map[string]struct {
+		metricName    string // Defaults to "c".
 		varLabels     []string
 		constLabels   []string
 		curriedLabels []string
@@ -48,7 +49,7 @@ func TestLabelCheck(t *testing.T) {
 			curriedLabels: []string{},
 			ok:            true,
 		},
-		"cade and method as var labels": {
+		"code and method as var labels": {
 			varLabels:     []string{"method", "code"},
 			constLabels:   []string{},
 			curriedLabels: []string{},
@@ -60,6 +61,12 @@ func TestLabelCheck(t *testing.T) {
 			curriedLabels: []string{"dings", "bums"},
 			ok:            true,
 		},
+		"all labels used with an invalid const label name": {
+			varLabels:     []string{"code", "method"},
+			constLabels:   []string{"in-valid", "bar"},
+			curriedLabels: []string{"dings", "bums"},
+			ok:            false,
+		},
 		"unsupported var label": {
 			varLabels:     []string{"foo"},
 			constLabels:   []string{},
@@ -96,17 +103,35 @@ func TestLabelCheck(t *testing.T) {
 			curriedLabels: []string{"method"},
 			ok:            false,
 		},
+		"invalid name and otherwise empty": {
+			metricName:    "in-valid",
+			varLabels:     []string{},
+			constLabels:   []string{},
+			curriedLabels: []string{},
+			ok:            false,
+		},
+		"invalid name with all the otherwise valid labels": {
+			metricName:    "in-valid",
+			varLabels:     []string{"code", "method"},
+			constLabels:   []string{"foo", "bar"},
+			curriedLabels: []string{"dings", "bums"},
+			ok:            false,
+		},
 	}
 
 	for name, sc := range scenarios {
 		t.Run(name, func(t *testing.T) {
+			metricName := sc.metricName
+			if metricName == "" {
+				metricName = "c"
+			}
 			constLabels := prometheus.Labels{}
 			for _, l := range sc.constLabels {
 				constLabels[l] = "dummy"
 			}
 			c := prometheus.NewCounterVec(
 				prometheus.CounterOpts{
-					Name:        "c",
+					Name:        metricName,
 					Help:        "c help",
 					ConstLabels: constLabels,
 				},
@@ -114,7 +139,7 @@ func TestLabelCheck(t *testing.T) {
 			)
 			o := prometheus.ObserverVec(prometheus.NewHistogramVec(
 				prometheus.HistogramOpts{
-					Name:        "c",
+					Name:        metricName,
 					Help:        "c help",
 					ConstLabels: constLabels,
 				},